Obama ditches the Freedom of Choice Act

uterine football Obama style

Obama knows passage of the FOCA would mean lasting reproductive Freedom for women, which in turn would allow women the Freedom to cross party lines more readily. So...Obama punts women into the abyss of ongoing begging for control over their own bodies, and ongoing servitude to the Blue party.
From NARAL, Pro-Choice America:

Freedom of Choice Act (FOCA) Fact Sheet
Excerpt from the full fact sheet:

Following the Supreme Court's closely divided decision to uphold the first-ever federal ban on abortion, it is clear that the stakes have changed and the right to choose is facing a new level of assault. That's why the pro-choice community supports guaranteeing the right to choose through the Freedom of Choice Act (FOCA) - a measure that would codify Roe v. Wade's protections and guarantee the right to choose for future generations of women.

By enacting FOCA, we will establish a federal law guaranteeing reproductive freedom for future generations of American women. This guarantee will protect women's rights NO MATTER WHO occupies the White House or is in control of Congress.

Obama’s Message to Congress: don’t send me the Freedom of Choice Act!
The Freedom of Choice Act is not on Obama’s priority list, said Mr. Obama last night during his celebrate-me press conference.

Wow, what a non-surprise. Obama picked Tim Kaine (pro-force male) to head the Party of Choice! Yeah, we’ve got your message, Mr. Obama. Immediately after the election you played politics with women's wombs. Yep, got it, women's freedom is something you can't be bothered with. What happened to "I can do more than one thing at a time." Last night as you preened about being such a smart, ambitious man who can not do too much, you somehow forgot about women?

The Dark House is the place where the sexist anti-femaleTim Favreau sits tight, the place where women’s repro health got dumped first out of the gate from your Spending Bill and you will do ONLY what is required of a Democratic president for women. Not one thing more. NON-progressive is Obama when it comes to women's rights.

Mr. Obama, you are a coward, unwilling to push ahead boldly for women’s rights. You are Such a coward that you can only say to the nation that abortion is a moral and ethical issue, NOT a woman’s freedom issue.

Message from Obama to women: you are sluts if you kill off man’s seed, and shame must remain the suit you wear.

By refusing to state that the right to control what happens in one's own body is a human rights issue Mr. Obama has set back women's rights.

Obama is sending a very clear message: I, Mr. Obama, will keep this political game over your wombs Hot and Happening, so women won’t run away to the fiscally conservative party.

Message from Obama to women: The Democratic party holds the keys to your wombs and we like it that way. NO WAY will I, Obama, rid the USA of the Hyde Amendment or allow Congress to bring forth a FOCA that will allow women lasting reproductive freedom.

I, Barack Hussein Obama, find it very advantageous to punt women’s uteruses hither and fro, as this is what tethers women to the Democratic Party. Women are too dumb to see this patent strategy of mine; I is one Cagey Smart dude!

Hail Mary and all that keeps her begging!
UPDATE: here is a link to UTube video in which Obama BALD faced lies, saying "the 1st thing i'd do as president is sign the Freedom Choice Act."

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pf0XIRZSTt8

Now, it looks like Obama has scrubbed his web site of this promise, but UTUBE will set you free! Also not the digg Obama takes at Clinton, saying "the Culture wars are so 90s." What does this guy take us for? By picking Tim Kaine to head up the DNC he is Stoking the Fires of Culture Wars, with is to say the WAR On Women.

Comments

While I commend you on taking

While I commend you on taking the president to task on FOCA and holding him accountable for his broken promise to women, I have to make two observations.

First, given his misogynistic attacks against Hillary and Sarah Palin during the campaign, is it really that surprising to see his dark side fully unmasked?

At pretty much every turn, the man lied and was called on it by the right, yet his staunch supporters brushed it all under the rug. He smeared Clinton and Palin, while the media -- along with many women's organizations, in the case of Palin -- not only defended him, but basically made the case that his female rivals weren't really women. When we can't even count on members of our own gender to admit that Palin is a shining example of the fruition of the women's rights movement (a woman who succeeded in her profession without sacrificing her role as a mother), then those organizations have essentially and effectively sold out to those who would make second-class citizens of us.

So, I'm sorry... but I'm not surprised that Obama is caught in yet another lie and betrayal of the people who supported him. It's unfortunate for all of you here that you're the ones betrayed -- and by extension, all women, whether we supported him or not are also betrayed -- because he decided to play politics with our uteruses, as you put it.

This man, regardless of his words in that press conference, doesn't have a principled or moral stance on the issue, and you need look no further than his legislative history in Illinois, where he was more than willing to allow fetuses which survived abortion to die without any medical treatment rather than allow them to be adopted out. In short, he doesn't have a consistent stand on the issue, unless consistency is measured in lies and broken promises.

Second, what do you intend to do about his betrayal? After all, you can talk all you want about how he's let you down, but if you continue to support him and his ilk, you'll merely get more of the same.

You're right that women's reproductive rights should be their business and no one else's -- not the government's and not society's. It's a matter between the woman, her doctor, and her conscience. Period. If that's what you want, then you need to see to it that you put your political support behind politicians who will pass FOCA into law. No, it won't fix everything, but as you said, it's a start.

On the flip side, you shouldn't press the government to provide the funds to pay for your abortion. (Not that I'm suggesting you or your site advocates that, but that is an argument I hear from the left.) If you can't pay for an abortion, don't expect government to pick up the tab...

In short, we all need to agree that moral choices should be left to individuals, rather than governments, which means government should support the rights of individuals to make their own moral choices, rather than place impediments blocking their way. FOCA is certainly the means by which we keep government out of our uteruses, but the likelihood of its passage just got a heckuva lot more difficult. Barry, "It's the very first thing I'll do when I take office" won't help you; so don't waste your time appealing to his sense of honor for he has none.

It's too bad you "feminists"

It's too bad you "feminists" didn't realize you didn't have to always tow the Dem line back when you could have made a real difference in the lives of women. Namely putting some support and effort into getting basic human rights for middle eastern women in the war areas. No, it was way more important to keep a united front against the evil Reps.

Thanks for kicking half our sisters to the curb you selfish jerks. Now you get a tiny taste of what it feels like.

hello, TickTock. Ok, first,

hello, TickTock.

Ok, first, so you might want to read some of our past items, such as why M.A. Liginter was "Punching it for Palin."

re your comment above, it is apt. and we did an item on what the Iraq war will mean for women's lives in the future as evidenced by the present:
Here is a link to War What is it Good For?
http://www.femisex.com/content/war-what%E2%80%99s-it-good-for

From the Jan. 29th Defying Hurdles story, this brilliant bit of good news:

Of the estimated 14,000 candidates, close to 4, 000 are women.

Wow….28% of the candidates were women! That is striking and a VERY big margin for hope. Now, of course, Iraqi women themselves will have to overcome their fear and bias against voting for women as much as Iraqi men. And while many will say: "oh she is SUCH a liar, or she is a SELL out, I’d rather have this man instead"….those votes that did not go to women will set Iraqi backwards more than anything else in its fledgling democratic history.

So hold those horses, b/c if FemiSex is anything it is NOT kneejerk. And the Feminists here are Big TENT feminists. Our overarching theme: zero tolerance to sexism from the Right or Left.

Maybe you fish do need a

Maybe you fish do need a bicycle! lol

Well, that is especially

Well, that is especially funny, given that my Christmas gift from my XY was...you guessed it: a new mountain bike!

Extremely inaccurate. No fan

Extremely inaccurate. No fan of Obama, but passing FOCA wouldn't somehow stop the abortion fight no matter who gains control of Congress or the Presidency in the future. For a law that can be passed can also be superceded by future law. In fact, that's what FOCA itself would be doing with all of the previous antiabortion laws. Gov 101, anyone?

The point is not whether it

The point is not whether it would do any good.

The point is that, IN HIS OWN WORDS, repealing FOCA would be the FIRST thing he would do to protect reproductive freedom. Now he says the FOCA is not a priority. So, logically, it means it will be a while before he does anything on the subject.

Now, I didn't vote for Obama, so this is absolutely no surprise to me. He was transparently full of it (in my opinion) on most every issue, picking the most politically expedient position, that he would then abandon as soon as it became inexpedient. And the few issues I believed him on I was completely against.

The Democrats have you over a barrel on this issue. They know most of you will never switch over to the Republicans _because_ of this issue, but if they pass it the issue largely becomes moot and it frees many of you to consider the Republican Party on other issues. They have NOTHING to gain, politically, in removing this issue from the political landscape. They need these sysiphean struggles to keep the one issue voters firmly in the Democratic camp. And yes, the Republicans have them too, but we all knew that Republicans are nakedly political and self-serving. And we all know that Democrats are above that. Right?

Hello Blah-- Ok, so I don't

Hello Blah--

Ok, so I don't know that the FOCA would solve ALL our problems in terms of choice, but I can say MUCH good would come of this act.

Here is a link to Wiki that gives a bit of back and forth on this topic, with the inclusion of an all-important issue of Intact Dilation and extraction.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_Choice_Act
From Wiki,
Opponents of FOCA assert that it would, if passed, invalidate every restriction on abortion nationwide, including parental notification laws, informed consent laws, and bans on partial birth abortion.[5] In the 50 American states, there are currently over 300 such laws.
----------------------
A FOCA would allow women, who are say, 2nd trimester and want to abort a trisomy 21 fetus, the choice of having a procedure that would be decided upon by their MD, not a JD!

Sort of like the Lily Ledbetter Bill, FOCA would undo damage done by the SC.
Not a panacea but...a very very good start!

Exactly why Obama has folded like a cheap suit on this issue-- the pro-force crowd is afraid of this in a very big way and they have good reason to be. They are telling Obama no way no how on this.
Pro-force crowd likes to bind women's uterues in hundreds of laws that make women beg for the right to control their bodies, or be subjected to biased propaganda, or force MDs to rant in ways they believe is harmful to their patients. FOCA would be an effective blow to these tactics and give a big gun in the arsenal of women. No it is not perfect, but it is good.

You pretty much nailed it on

You pretty much nailed it on the head here... it's not about pro-choice or pro-life; it's all about pro-force. The trouble with our current government (and this was true even before the dems took control of both houses and the WH) is that our government is trending toward totalitarianism -- it's all about telling people how they'll conduct their lives... how energy efficient we should be, how much we should weigh, how much money we can make (and how much is too much), how we should use our uteruses. It hardly matters who's in charge, the result will be more government control over our lives and our choices. The only difference is that you may agree with some of what the government wants when one party is in control versus the other, but that will always change when their political fortunes change.

I return, then, to the point I made in another reply, that in the end we all need to start fighting for the government to refrain from making moral choices for us and allow us to make those decisions for ourselves.

As for FOCA, from what little I've read, it seems to make it pretty clear that government is stay out of a woman's uterus. Now, maybe the pro-life crowd could find some way to get around that, but it would be pretty hard...

I'm not at all surprised at

I'm not at all surprised at Obama's abandonment of FOCA or his indifference to reproductive rights. I am surprised that otherwise intelligent people continue to project their hopes and aspirations onto a blank screen, wailing in disappointment when he fails to live up to or fulfill them.

I'm baffled at the cult-like hold he still exerts over so many, especially the chattering classes. Don't expect the media to pay attention to Obama's cavalier disregard of women's issues. They haven't held him accountable for hundreds of broken promises thus far, they won't do it for this one.

And be careful how you go about criticizing him. I'm sure none of you have any particular sympathy for Sarah Palin or Miss California, but they serve as excellent examples of what the forces of tolerance will do to women who express unapproved opinions. It's not just conservative or right-leaning women who will get the treatment, and if you don't believe me, try raising a bigger stink about this. There's still a lot of room under that bus.

Its just pure cold-eyed and

Its just pure cold-eyed and cynical calculation from the man who was hailed as the new Messiah. We tried to warn people.

As the late, great John Belushi might have said: "But noooooooooooo. We were just racists who couldn't stand the thought of a Black Man in the White House."

Face facts. The Democratic Party owns you. Where else are you going to go? They want your votes. They sure want your money. But when the election is over they want you to shut the hell up because they aren't really going to *do* anything for you.

And you guys actually thought

And you guys actually thought Mr. Obama was a man of his word? Hey. There was never any evidence that he would do anything other than what was personally politically expedient. Put me down as a member of the 48% who saw through him from the start. Shoulda gone with Hillary.

I would have thought Obama

I would have thought Obama was playing it on the low down, you know, getting reproductive laws passed in a back door approach instead of the frontal assualt of the Foca. But with his talk about morals, gotta say, it stinks, stanks, stunk.

You are right the only way to end the to and fro of abortions rights between liberal and conservative administrations is to pass the Foca. I am deeply disappointed in Obama, and I campaigned for the guy.

I am not a big comment

I am not a big comment person, but twice now I have come from my shadow to give kudos to femisex. Not only do you castigate Mr. Obama for breaking his promise, but you give a very clear reason why he has chosen to do so.

I made a point to go to the conf. room and turn on the tv, and watch the news. I only looked at one broadcast, but not a single menton of Obama's broken FOCA pledge. The station I looked at even did a segment on Obama and his upcoming speech at Notre Dame, but didn't mention the tie in to last night's press conference question. I no longer believe it is worth my while to read the traditional feminist web sites and a quick check today confirmed my leanings. Salon has a vapid story berating the beauty contestant from California, but not a word about Mr. Obama and FOCA.

I fear it is a long cold winter for women as 2nd class inhabitants of this earth.

I am a catholic, raised on it, as they say. In my adult life I've always felt that the dogma of abortion in my church was and is based on numbers--the more catholics there are the better for the Church. Femisex has pointed out that Obama is taking the same tack--by keeping women beholden to the party he ensures a massive female vote for him and his party in coming elections. It is all a numbers game, cost to women be damned.
So abortion is highly moral issue says Mr. Obama. Yes that was the threat I was raised on, hell and brimstone. Once you attach the word morality to an issue there are only two options: the moral one and the immoral one. I was heartbroken to see Mr. Obama using talking points on morality and abortion taken straight from the Church.
So once again I must write and thank this blog for just existing. I am sure it is hard to swim against the tide, but I feel you will be rewarded. I don't feel immoral because I had an abortion. But I do feel it is very immoral for Mr. Obama to lay that crap at my feet all over again. Please keep up your push for framing abortion as a human rights issue. Countless women can be helped by simple stopping the moral threat talk when it comes to abortion.
I plan to raise any child I may have on a strict diet of reproductive freedom as a human rights issue and put the guilt game to rest once and for all. Quite frankly, my child will most likely always have access to abortion given that I'm solidly middle class, but I can't assure that she won't internalize society-built shame if she needed to exercise her human right to choose when or if to have a family.

Obama says he has "a task

Obama says he has "a task force" working with both prochoice and prolife groups. Is it too much for him to keep his promise to support the Freedom Of Choice plan?.

just found this link
http://feministlawprofessors.com/?p=10357
for some mild rebuke.

It is scary quiet out there.

It is scary quiet out there. Almost like the so-called feminists are afraid to be critical of Mr. Obama. Feministing is still jabbering on about what an "asshole" Miss California is, with not a single a critical word about Obama on his support of "opposite marriage" or his F-U to FOCA.

I see no msm stories about Obama's fractured pledge to women.
What the hell? What universe do I live in? Women are NOT afraid to pick fights with other women, but give kid glove treatment to males who dissappoint them, esp on male who so many voted to be their president.

"Message from Obama to women:

"Message from Obama to women: The Democratic party holds the keys to your wombs and we like it that way. NO WAY will I, Obama rid the USA of the Hyde Amendment or allow Congress to bring forth a FOCA that will allow women lasting reproductive freedom. I, Barack Hussein Obama, find it very advantageous to punt women’s uteruses hither and fro, as this is what tethers women to the Democratic Party."

Yes, you have nailed it. Tim Kaine made me leary, but last night, puts the stamp on it. This guy thinks women are about as smart as grass.

I just called NARAL and told

I just called NARAL and told them how dissappointed I was and continue to be in Nancy Keenan's choice to endorse Obama over Hillary. I told NARAL not one more penny from me until Nancy steps down. I also told them about your article and wondered why nothing on their web site yet.
Here is NARAL contact in case others want to call in concerns.
thanks for covering this.

NARAL Pro-Choice America
1156 15th Street, NW Suite 700
Washington, DC 20005

Main Number: 202.973.3000

Readers have requested a

Readers have requested a transcript of Obama on the FOCA from last night's press conf. Here you go!

QUESTION: Thank you, Mr. President. In a couple of weeks, you're going to be giving the commencement at Notre Dame. And, as you know, this has caused a lot of controversy among Catholics who are opposed to your position on abortion.

As a candidate, you vowed that one of the very things you wanted to do was sign the Freedom of Choice Act, which, as you know, would eliminate federal, state and local restrictions on abortion. And at one point in the campaign when asked about abortion and life, you said that it was above -- quote, "above my pay grade."

Now that you've been president for 100 days, obviously, your pay grade is a little higher than when you were a senator.

(LAUGHTER)

Do you still hope that Congress quickly sends you the Freedom of Choice Act so you can sign it?

OBAMA: You know, the -- my view on -- on abortion, I think, has been very consistent. I think abortion is a moral issue and an ethical issue.

I think that those who are pro-choice make a mistake when they -- if they suggest -- and I don't want to create straw men here, but I think there are some who suggest that this is simply an issue about women's freedom and that there's no other considerations. I think, look, this is an issue that people have to wrestle with and families and individual women have to wrestle with.

OBAMA: The reason I'm pro-choice is because I don't think women take that -- that position casually. I think that they struggle with these decisions each and every day. And I think they are in a better position to make these decisions ultimately than members of Congress or a president of the United States, in consultation with their families, with their doctors, with their doctors, with their clergy.

So -- so that has been my consistent position. The other thing that I said consistently during the campaign is I would like to reduce the number of unwanted presidencies that result in women feeling compelled to get an abortion, or at least considering getting an abortion, particularly if we can reduce the number of teen pregnancies, which has started to spike up again.

And so I've got a task force within the Domestic Policy Council in the West Wing of the White House that is working with groups both in the pro-choice camp and in the pro-life camp, to see if we can arrive at some consensus on that.

Now, the Freedom of Choice Act is not highest legislative priority. I believe that women should have the right to choose. But I think that the most important thing we can do to tamp down some of the anger surrounding this issue is to focus on those areas that we can agree on. And that's -- that's where I'm going to focus

I went to the traditional

I went to the traditional feminist sites and can't find a word about Obama FOCA disposal. Wow, nothing. CNN is ignoring it as well. Very disheartening.

I did find this
http://edgeoforever.wordpress.com/
that says Obama promised Planned Parenthood he'd sigh the FOCA 1st thng off the bat.
ugh.

And I wonder what Nancy Keenan, who supported Obama over Hillary has to say about this public dissertion of FOCA.

Yes, Femisex you have been

Yes, Femisex you have been saying this for a while. And last night Mr. Obama made it very clear that he can do all sorts of things but not that thing that would really make change for women.
Keep up your music Femisex. Women will soon demand more than the eternal back and forth game of bodily freedom.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options